Fish tracker

Pull a Lucky Fish Fish List And Rarity Tracker

This is not a complete official fish list yet. Entries are source-labeled so rare, secret, hidden, and mutation signals can be checked before final rankings.

Fish table

Candidate fish and rarity signals

Name	Type	Rarity/status	Confidence	Notes
Colorless Fish	Fish	Needs check	Community caption	Candidate name from gameplay auto-caption.
Puffer Fish	Fish	Needs check	Community caption	Candidate name needs visual confirmation.
Alien Fish	Fish	Needs check	Community caption	Repeated caption signal; exact rarity not verified.
Prism Fish	Fish	Needs check	Community caption	Candidate for rare-fish tracking.
Molted Fish	Fish	Needs check	Low	Caption may have misheard the exact name.
Codfish	Fish	Mutation lead	Community caption	Caption mentions Blood Moon and bloody Codfish chance.
Sunfish	Fish	Needs check	Community caption	Candidate name needs visual confirmation.
Dolphin	Sea creature	Needs check	Community caption	May be a catchable entity; verify on-screen label.
Voidfish	Fish	Secret lead	Community caption	Candidate for secret/hidden rarity checks.
Dumbbell	Unclear entity	Hold	Low	May not be a fish; do not rank until visually confirmed.

How to use this list

Treat every row as a verification task

Pull a Lucky Fish is young enough that captions, short videos, and search snippets can move faster than reliable documentation. This tracker keeps those leads useful without turning them into false certainty.

When you catch a fish, record the exact on-screen name, rarity text, whether a mutation or event label is visible, and whether the fish can be placed on your island for income. That single screenshot can move a row from needs-check to source-backed.

Ranking readiness

What is still missing before final tiers

The best-fish question depends on more than rarity. A rare fish can still be a poor upgrade target if it needs a rod you cannot afford, appears beyond your cast range, or earns less island money than another catch.

Final rankings need fish income, rarity labels, access requirements, and replacement value. Until those pieces are checked, use this page with the income planner and tier list rather than treating any community caption as a finished wiki entry.

Source-backed

Fish are the core collection target

The official Roblox description confirms players cast, catch, and place fish on their island.

Needs check

Income rates are missing

Do not treat any fish as best value until island income rates are confirmed.

Next step

Capture on-screen labels

A screenshot can confirm fish name, rarity, income, and whether a mutation is active.

Tier list Income planner Money guide